Home Alone for Christmas

The perennial argument piece, often dismissed by serious critics for its cartoon logic, yet stubbornly insisting on its place in the Christmas canon. But I say, look deeper than the flung paint cans and the slapstick violence, and you find a film that is, low-key, the best Christmas movie ever made.

It is, first and foremost, a perfectly engineered piece of cinema. Director Chris Columbus and writer John Hughes—a pairing as potent as Scorsese and De Niro, in their own genre—understood the emotional landscape of childhood. The central conceit isn't just about being left behind; it’s about an eight-year-old’s fantasy of absolute, unregulated autonomy, realized at the most magical time of year. Who among us, as a child, didn't wish the tyrannical adults would simply vanish so we could eat ice cream and watch questionable movies?

The film succeeds where many Christmas pictures fail: it treats its spiritual components with a delicate, almost secular grace. The heart of the picture is not the chaotic action, but two moments of quiet reflection. There is the scene with the department store Santa, where Kevin makes his wish—a childlike prayer for his family's return. More importantly, there is the beautiful, understated conversation with Old Man Marley in the church. It is a moment of pure, unforced human connection, an exchange of wisdom about family and forgiveness that is genuinely moving. It is the real It's a Wonderful Life moment of the film.

And let us not forget the John Williams score. It is a work of genius, simultaneously conveying the wonder of the season and the terror of a child besieged. It elevates what could have been a mere sketch into a minor epic.

So yes, it is ludicrously implausible. But great cinema often deals in elevated reality. Home Alone strips Christmas down to its essentials: family, home, and the pure, primal wish to be safe. It is a holiday classic because it earns its sentimentality the hard way, through a gauntlet of hot door knobs and icy steps.

← Back to Field Notes